GENETIC TESTING MALPRACTICE
PRENATAL SCREENING
Prenatal screening for genetic disorders has become a mainstream part of obstetric practice. These screenings will show parents whether they have an increased risk of having a fetus that might be affected by a genetic disorder. It is sometimes recommended that parents that are at high risk of having a baby with a genetic disorder due to both parents being carriers, choose not to conceive together, and to consider using a donor if they wish to have children.
PRENATAL TESTING
Prenatal testing during pregnancy is designed to actually test the fetus to see there is a genetic disorder present. Unfortunately, the testing is not 100% accurate and there are many false negatives and false positives that occur, leaving parents with difficult decisions. A false negative could result in a baby being born with a genetic disorder, and a false negative could cause the termination of a healthy fetus. This leaves parents with difficult decisions, and has given rise to a large number of lawsuits for wrongful abortion and wrongful birth.
AMNIOCENTESIS
Amniocentesis is the most accurate test, and is recommended for women over the age of 35. Testing can be done early, if requested, and if there is a family history of genetic disorders. It is usually performed between 14 and 20 weeks, and involves taking a sample of the amniotic fluid through a needle. This test is more accurate than others, but still has some percentage of false positives and negatives.
NEGLIGENCE
In addition to the flaws inherent to testing that if performed properly, there is sometimes negligence in the testing process. There is an expectation that genetic testing will be done properly, that the correct tests will be given, that the laboratory will perform the tests properly and that the doctors will interpret the results correctly. This is when families that that suffered with a wrongful birth should contact an experienced genetic malpractice attorney.
These are some situations from recent cases where the expectation of proper testing was not correct:
- Failure to offer genetic counseling to a family
- Failure to provide appropriate prenatal testing
- Errors by the laboratory
- Doctors did not accurately interpret results
- Medical professional failing to carry out orders
FAILURE TO OFFER GENETIC COUNSELING
Some younger mothers may decide to have testing based on their family history, and to test early in the pregnancy. Those decisions should be made with the benefit of genetic counseling. If no testing is done, and a baby is born with a genetic disorder, the failure of the medical office to recommend it, will present serious liability. Genetic counseling is a very important part of the process as informed consent must be obtained for the decision to either terminate or continue a pregnancy in light of the information that the testing provides. Parents must be counseled about the impact of a genetic disorder on a person’s health, and also about the statistics of false positives and negatives. Failure to offer this counseling leaves the medical profesionals vulnerable to a lawsuit, should the decision that was made by the parents, turn out to be a bad one.
FAILURE TO PROVIDE APPROPRIATE GENETIC TESTING
Testing must be offered to all mothers based on the results of their genetic counseling, their health history and their age. Failure to arrange for this testing, should a baby be born with a genetic disorder, would clearly be malpractice. The testing must also be appropriate, if a mother that is under 35 is given an amniocentesis that causes a spontaneous abortion with a good reason for having the testing done, the doctor can be liable for this inappropriate testing.
ERRORS AT THE LABORATORY
Human error can play a part in any disaster, and errors at laboratories are common. Sometimes the wrong sample is tested or the beaker is contaminated. These mistakes can cause false positives or negatives regarding the health of a fetus. When this happens the laboratory is obviously liable, but the doctors can also be responsible if they based their decision solely on the testing, and did not apply common sense that might be needed, such as checking the patient’s history.
DOCTORS DID NOT CORRECTLY INTERPRET THE RESULTS
Test results must be interpreted by a doctor, and sometimes they are not interpreted correctly. It could be that the results were written on the wrong patient’s chart or that the doctor was not familiar enough with the testing and the disorders. This gives rise to liability should a decision be made to terminate a pregnancy or a pregnancy continues with an unexpected result.
WRONGFUL ABORTION
An evolving area of the law surrounds cases where negligence is alleged that caused them to terminate a pregnancy with a health fetus. This loss of a fetus can be actionable where the decision was based the wrong information. These cases often turn on the psychological and emotional harm that the family feels when they find out that they have terminated a healthy pregnancy.
WRONGFUL BIRTH
These sad cases are for children who were born with devastating diseases that could have been diagnosed with genetic testing very early in the pregnancy. The quality of life for these children can be close to non-existent, and the parents must suffer through this anguish and experience economic loss due to the astronomical cost of caring for these severely disabled children. We understand that this is a serious issue, and that not all parents might elect to end a pregnancy no matter the testing results are, but parents should be given the option of testing, and the testing should be done correctly to determine what genetic problems a fetus might have. Some genetic problems cause disabilities that might cause a child to have a disability such as Down’s Syndrome or Dwarfism that might make their lives more difficult, but with proper support, well worth living. There are other genetic problems that are so devastating that there is virtually no quality of life. That’s when you might consider bringing an action for wrongful birth with a genetic malpractice attorney. If your family is living with the aftermath of wrongful birth, you owe it to yourselves to contact a genetic medical malpractice attorney for a consultation.
Do I Have The Right NYC Coronavirus Personal Injury Lawyer?
Coronavirus restrictions have shut down physical access to most attorney’s offices, but that doesn’t have to mean your case is sitting idle in a file cabinet. It does mean it’s important to choose a firm that is prepared to handle both existing and new cases efficiently no matter how long this crisis lasts. Smart attorneys with offices that are paperless, cloud based and equipped with video conferencing technology can still handle your cases successfully. You just need to make sure your case is with a NYC Coronavirus Personal Injury Lawyer that’s up and running. Wittenstein & Wittenstein is the NYC Personal Injury Law Firm that’s been on the forefront of technology for over 60 years - trust us to take care of your case during these trying times. The Status of the New York Legal System All of the physical courthouses in New York are closed to the public, but there’s still action behind the scenes. Documentsyou are being e-filed, depositions, arbitrations and mediations are being held virtually with cases proceeding to trial. Trials themselves are on hold indefinitely, but [...]
NEW YORK CORONAVIRUS INJURY LAWYER
The Coronavirus pandemic has changed life as we know it in New York. We’re worried about our health, and the health of our friends and neighbors, doing everything we can to avoid spreading the disease. Some people with sick relatives may be wondering about their legal options if they or a family member contracts the disease. It’s important to know that it’s possible to collect compensation for personal injury or wrongful death from persons or entities that are responsible for the infection. That’s why it’s important to speak to a Coronavirus Injury Lawyer if you believe you or your loved one’s infection could have been prevented. Wittenstein & Wittenstein is a New York Coronavirus Lawyer that’s been handling infectious disease cases for over 60 years. We can determine whether negligence or recklessness caused a Coronavirus infection and pursue collecting money damages on your behalf. A New York Coronavirus Injury Lawyer Can Determine Who’s Responsible for a Coronavirus Infection In order to make a liability claim for a Coronavirus infection, it’s necessary to prove that the infection was preventable if proper [...]
COVID 19 CRISIS ANNOUNCEMENT
We are hoping that you and your family are well and managing this crisis smoothly. Please let us know if there is anything at all we can do to help you. Our office is located on the first floor of a townhouse that is accessible without social contact, so we’re planning to remain fully operational throughout this crisis. Don’t hesitate to call on us if you’re in need. Please DO NOT show up at our office without an appointment - we are doing all work remotely at this time. Your Current Cases Are Being Worked On All of the civil courts are currently closed. We are working on rescheduling court appearances, depositions and other important litigation dates. It’s best that you continue to treat your injuries as long as possible. If your medical provider’s office closes, you can keep a record of the exercises you do at home. Be on the lookout for our letter and treatment affidavits coming in the mail. Please call us for instructions when you receive the letter. As long as insurance companies remain open, we [...]
Your Rights During The Coronavirus Pandemic
I have been saddened to hear so many stories about Asians and Asian-Americans being treated badly during this current health crisis. This is riding on the heels of nasty rhetoric from the Trump administration regarding immigrants and refugees. It’s important to know that Federal, New York State and New York City law prohibits discrimination in employment, housing and public accomodations. New York City laws are the strongest of all, prohibiting discriminatory lending practices, retaliation, discriminatory harassment and bias-based profiling by law enforcement. Who Is Protected From Discrimination? The purpose of discrimination laws is to protect people that are vulnerable to being treated poorly in our culture. Treating somebody badly for personal reasons or grudges is not legally actionable as discrimination. For example, you can be denied employment because the owner of a business hates your sister or refused service in a restaurant because the manager doesn’t like your mom. In New York City law prohibits dicrimination based on: Age Alienage or citizenship status Color Disability Gender (including sexual harassment) Gender Identity Marital status and partnership status National origin Pregnancy and [...]
What’s The Hype About Stacey Abrams?
We might just be seeing Stacey Abrams on the ticket for the 2020 Presidential election. The former Democratic Leader of the Georgia House of Representatives, and 2018 Democratic Party contender for Governor of Georgia, is being courted by several of the Democratic Presidential candidates as a running mate. This savvy Yale graduate was the first black woman to become the gubernatorial nominee for a major party and has launched “Fair Fight,” a voting rights organization taking the initiative on funding the training of voter protection teams in twenty battleground states. If she’s not on the ticket this year, she’s young enough to make a go at it later. In fact, she told “The Hill,” in January that she “plans to be President by 2040.” I hope her dream comes true because she’s the kind of lady that brings brilliance, unity and humility to everything she does. Getting Out The Vote It’s ironic that Abrams, who has devoted herself to supporting voting rights, lost the race for Georgia governor in a very close election. This has fueled her desire to work [...]
My Time With Ruth
I’m eternally grateful that I had the opportunity to study Constitutional Law with Ruth Bader Ginsburg during the Summer of 1996. She remains a great inspiration to me, inspiring me to share some of her contributions with you today. She’s a groundbreaking lawyer, women’s rights activist and Supreme Court Justice that’s changed the World. Early Life and Career Ruth Bader Ginsburg was born in Brooklyn in 1933, daughter of a furrier and a garment worker. She was an exceptional student, graduating first in her class from Cornell, and from there she became one of the few women in her class at Harvard Law School. Later she became the first female member of the prestigious Harvard Law Review. She married Martin Ginsburg, also an attorney, who shared responsibility for caring for the couple’s children and household. After spending some time teaching, she went on to serve as the director of the ACLU Women’s Rights Project, arguing six landmark cases on gender equality before the Supreme Court. The Road To The Supreme Court She was appointed by President Carter to serve in [...]