GENETIC TESTING MALPRACTICE
PRENATAL SCREENING
Prenatal screening for genetic disorders has become a mainstream part of obstetric practice. These screenings will show parents whether they have an increased risk of having a fetus that might be affected by a genetic disorder. It is sometimes recommended that parents that are at high risk of having a baby with a genetic disorder due to both parents being carriers, choose not to conceive together, and to consider using a donor if they wish to have children.
PRENATAL TESTING
Prenatal testing during pregnancy is designed to actually test the fetus to see there is a genetic disorder present. Unfortunately, the testing is not 100% accurate and there are many false negatives and false positives that occur, leaving parents with difficult decisions. A false negative could result in a baby being born with a genetic disorder, and a false negative could cause the termination of a healthy fetus. This leaves parents with difficult decisions, and has given rise to a large number of lawsuits for wrongful abortion and wrongful birth.
AMNIOCENTESIS
Amniocentesis is the most accurate test, and is recommended for women over the age of 35. Testing can be done early, if requested, and if there is a family history of genetic disorders. It is usually performed between 14 and 20 weeks, and involves taking a sample of the amniotic fluid through a needle. This test is more accurate than others, but still has some percentage of false positives and negatives.
NEGLIGENCE
In addition to the flaws inherent to testing that if performed properly, there is sometimes negligence in the testing process. There is an expectation that genetic testing will be done properly, that the correct tests will be given, that the laboratory will perform the tests properly and that the doctors will interpret the results correctly. This is when families that that suffered with a wrongful birth should contact an experienced genetic malpractice attorney.
These are some situations from recent cases where the expectation of proper testing was not correct:
- Failure to offer genetic counseling to a family
- Failure to provide appropriate prenatal testing
- Errors by the laboratory
- Doctors did not accurately interpret results
- Medical professional failing to carry out orders
FAILURE TO OFFER GENETIC COUNSELING
Some younger mothers may decide to have testing based on their family history, and to test early in the pregnancy. Those decisions should be made with the benefit of genetic counseling. If no testing is done, and a baby is born with a genetic disorder, the failure of the medical office to recommend it, will present serious liability. Genetic counseling is a very important part of the process as informed consent must be obtained for the decision to either terminate or continue a pregnancy in light of the information that the testing provides. Parents must be counseled about the impact of a genetic disorder on a person’s health, and also about the statistics of false positives and negatives. Failure to offer this counseling leaves the medical profesionals vulnerable to a lawsuit, should the decision that was made by the parents, turn out to be a bad one.
FAILURE TO PROVIDE APPROPRIATE GENETIC TESTING
Testing must be offered to all mothers based on the results of their genetic counseling, their health history and their age. Failure to arrange for this testing, should a baby be born with a genetic disorder, would clearly be malpractice. The testing must also be appropriate, if a mother that is under 35 is given an amniocentesis that causes a spontaneous abortion with a good reason for having the testing done, the doctor can be liable for this inappropriate testing.
ERRORS AT THE LABORATORY
Human error can play a part in any disaster, and errors at laboratories are common. Sometimes the wrong sample is tested or the beaker is contaminated. These mistakes can cause false positives or negatives regarding the health of a fetus. When this happens the laboratory is obviously liable, but the doctors can also be responsible if they based their decision solely on the testing, and did not apply common sense that might be needed, such as checking the patient’s history.
DOCTORS DID NOT CORRECTLY INTERPRET THE RESULTS
Test results must be interpreted by a doctor, and sometimes they are not interpreted correctly. It could be that the results were written on the wrong patient’s chart or that the doctor was not familiar enough with the testing and the disorders. This gives rise to liability should a decision be made to terminate a pregnancy or a pregnancy continues with an unexpected result.
WRONGFUL ABORTION
An evolving area of the law surrounds cases where negligence is alleged that caused them to terminate a pregnancy with a health fetus. This loss of a fetus can be actionable where the decision was based the wrong information. These cases often turn on the psychological and emotional harm that the family feels when they find out that they have terminated a healthy pregnancy.
WRONGFUL BIRTH
These sad cases are for children who were born with devastating diseases that could have been diagnosed with genetic testing very early in the pregnancy. The quality of life for these children can be close to non-existent, and the parents must suffer through this anguish and experience economic loss due to the astronomical cost of caring for these severely disabled children. We understand that this is a serious issue, and that not all parents might elect to end a pregnancy no matter the testing results are, but parents should be given the option of testing, and the testing should be done correctly to determine what genetic problems a fetus might have. Some genetic problems cause disabilities that might cause a child to have a disability such as Down’s Syndrome or Dwarfism that might make their lives more difficult, but with proper support, well worth living. There are other genetic problems that are so devastating that there is virtually no quality of life. That’s when you might consider bringing an action for wrongful birth with a genetic malpractice attorney. If your family is living with the aftermath of wrongful birth, you owe it to yourselves to contact a genetic medical malpractice attorney for a consultation.
How to Avoid Being Dropped by Insurance Companies
Can My Insurance Company Drop Me? Here at Wittenstein & Wittenstein, rarely does a day go by without somebody asking us if their insurance company can drop them. People pay for insurance, but are afraid to use it for fear of being dropped. That’s why we thought it would be helpful to address this, and the related issue of when an insurance company can raise your rates. When Can My Insurance Company Drop Me? An insurance company can drop you whenever they’d like to, and no reason is required. Most of the time however, insurance companies like to keep their customers. So they’re not likely to drop you unless it starts to look like they’ll have to pay out a lot more than what they collect from you. Insurance companies can do this through cancellation or non-renewal. Cancellation Cancellation is when an insurance company stops covering you during the term of your contract. This typically occurs if you’ve violated the terms of agreement in one of the following ways: 1. You fail to report an accident or violate other policy [...]
5 Things You Need to Know About DUI in NYC
No one who is going out for a night out on the town expects to end up arrested and in the back of a police car. Unfortunately, that can happen when poor choices are made in regard to drinking and driving. Do you know what to expect with a DUI arrest? Here are five things you need to know about a DUI in New York City. Impaired to "Any Extent" The difference between DWI and DWAI can literally just be .01 percent. According to FindLaw, driving while intoxicated (DWI) is defined as having a blood alcohol content at .08 percent or higher. Driving while ability impaired (DWAI) could be assigned if the blood alcohol content is between .05 percent and .07 percent. Even though a DWAI is considered a lesser offense, it can still result in a jail sentence of up to 15 days and as much as $500 in fines. With a DWI conviction, the fines are higher, the jail time can be longer, and there is always a risk of having your license suspended. Both of these charges [...]
Black History Month Spotlight: Michelle Obama
Black History Month- Recognizing Notable Lawyer: Michelle Obama We’ve seen Michelle Obama poised by Barack Obama’s side during his presidency countless times. Fashionable and statuesque, she handled her position as first lady with a deftness and grace that belied the initial criticism she faced. For eight years, she proudly served as the premiere African-American first lady. There is so much more to know about Michelle Obama - here are some things you might not be aware of: 1. She is one of only three first ladies with a Graduate Degree. After graduating Magna Cum Laude with her Bachelors Degree in Sociology from Princeton University, Michelle Obama went on to receive her Law Degree from Harvard Law School. The other first ladies with Graduate Degrees are Hillary Clinton, who also received a Law Degree and Laura Bush who earned a Masters in Library Science. 2. She is one smart cookie! Michelle Obama showed academic promise long before Princeton and Harvard. She skipped the 2nd grade during elementary school, and graduated as salutatorian from her high school. 3. She was Barack Obama’s [...]
HERE’S WHAT YOU SHOULD DO AFTER A CAR ACCIDENT
Nobody is truly prepared for a car accident. Sometimes it’s just a nuisance fender-bender with property damage, but other times it can be a life-altering event. Usually, it’s someplace in-between. Since accidents are so common in New York City, it’s a good idea to know what to do in case you have a car accident. Wittenstein & Wittenstein is a law firm with accident attorneys in Queens that will answer all your questions after accident. They also share some basic information about what to do. THE FIVE MOST IMPORTANT THINGS TO DO RIGHT AFTER A CAR ACCIDENT Call the police (911). Never make an agreement with the other vehicles to exchange information and handle everything “without the insurance.” This puts you in great jeopardy. If somebody is hurt, they can sue you, and claim you “left the scene,” and if you don’t file with your insurance company, they may say that you violated the policy, and refuse to defend you. It’s also sometimes hard to tell if you were hurt right after an accident and the insurance company may not [...]
Common Questions after a Truck Accident
Have you ever seen an 18-wheeler, semi-truck, tractor-trailer, or big rig crash into car? Have you ever wondered what would happen if that car was yours and you were driving? The tragedy of such a situation can be mitigated with knowledge about what to do. At NYC truck accident lawyer Wittenstein & Wittenstein we can put your mind at ease and take care of all the details for you, so you can concentrate on getting better. Truck accidents can cause catastrophic injuries, and long-term disability. Victims need an attorney with the experience to properly handle these more complicated claims. There are often multiple defendants, such as drivers, trucking companies, municipalities (for defects on the road) and manufacturers (for design defects in the truck.) When catastrophic injuries occur, an experienced Brooklyn traffic accident attorney will leave no stone unturned to get the highest amount of compensation from all possible sources. THE FIRST THING TO DO AFTER A TRUCK ACCIDENT Document Everything Take photos of the vehicles and your injuries Take videos of the vehicles and your injuries Interview witnesses (try to [...]
Are You Underinsured?
Suppose you were walking on the sidewalk, minding your own business, and an out-of-control car came up onto the sidewalk and knocked you over, causing very serious injuries. You might never be able to work again, and are expecting a large amount of compensation. You’d be very disappointed to find out that the car that hit you only carried the minimum amount of insurance. Someone with a minimum policy in New York would have the following policy limits: Bodily Injury liability coverage: $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident Property Damage liability coverage: $10,000 per accident Uninsured Bodily Injury coverage: $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident Personal Injury Protection: $50,000 If you were to get struck by a vehicle, the most money you can obtain for your injuries as per the minimum bodily injury liability coverage limits would be $25,000 (and that’s before attorney fees). Accidents occur when we least expect them. Being adequately insured and prepared in the event of an accident helps ensure a smoother and stress free process after the fact. WHAT CAN YOU DO [...]